Guide
Order picking: methods compared
Picking methods differ in who moves (person to goods or goods to person), how many orders are handled at once (order by order or in batches) and how information reaches the picker (paper list or paperless, e.g. by scanner, light or voice).
Picking means assembling items from stock according to orders. How it is done depends on item count, order structure and equipment. The literature mainly distinguishes three questions: does the person move to the goods or do the goods come to the person? Is each order handled on its own or are several handled together? And how does the picker learn what to take? This overview explains the terms in general.
At a glance
| Question | Variants | Typical for |
|---|---|---|
| Who moves? | person to goods · goods to person | manual warehouses · automated warehouses |
| How many orders? | single-stage (order by order) · two-stage (batch, then split) | few large orders · many small orders |
| How does information arrive? | paper list · paperless (scanner, light, voice) | low volumes · high volumes, error control |
Decision table: which method fits?
| Your situation | Obvious method | Why |
|---|---|---|
| few orders with many lines | single-stage, order by order | each order is completed in one pass |
| many small orders with the same items | two-stage (collect, then split) | fewer trips per item |
| high cost of errors | paperless with scan matching | item and location are checked; quantity checks depend on the method |
| pallet orders | pallet picking per recipient | whole pallets or layers rather than single items |
Example: weekly store replenishment
A store chain orders 30 to 40 lines each week for twelve stores, many of them the same items. Picked order by order, staff walk to the same slots twelve times. In two-stage picking, all quantities of an item for all stores are taken first and then split between the twelve store shipments. That saves trips but needs space for splitting and clear labelling per store. What this looks like as a service: order picking in Berlin.
Avoiding errors: check before packing
Most picking errors are mix-ups of similar items and wrong quantities. Effective measures are a check against the order list before packing, clear location labels and – where errors are costly – confirming each pick by scan. Which check makes sense depends on what an error costs: more for spare parts for a stopped machine than for consumables.
What to analyse for a quote
- Orders per day and week, including peaks
- Lines per order (average and maximum)
- Share of carton and pallet orders
- Items with batch, serial number or shelf life (see FIFO and FEFO)
- Documents and labels per recipient
Order picking step by step
- Order arrives by the cut-off
- Order is released and – depending on the method – batched with others
- Lines are picked at the storage location
- Check against the order list
- Packing and securing, delivery note and label
- Staging for collection, stock is booked out
Order picking KPIs
| KPI | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Lines per hour | picking output |
| Error rate | share of wrongly or incompletely picked lines |
| Lead time | time from order release to staging |
| On-time rate | share of orders ready at the agreed time |
Key terms
- Order picking: assembling items from stock according to an order
- Line: one order line with item and quantity
- Pick: a single retrieval at the storage location
- Batch: several orders picked together
- Paperless: picking without a paper list, e.g. by scanner
How is picking done? Aids at a glance
The aids are independent of the picking method: serial single-order picking can run by scan or by list. For your quote it matters most whether items are scanned – the basis for batch and quantity checks.
| Method | How it works | Suits |
|---|---|---|
| Pick by paper | picker works through a printed list | few orders, simple range |
| Pick by scan | handheld shows location and quantity, item is scanned | batches, serial numbers, high accuracy |
| Pick by voice | instructions and confirmation by voice | work where hands must stay free |
| Pick by light | lights at the slot show picks and quantity | many small orders from fixed slots |
ABC analysis: which items should sit where
A common classification follows the Pareto principle: a few items account for most picks (A items), many items are picked rarely (C items). A items sit close to staging and at grip height, C items further away. As the client you only need to give the warehouse an analysis of order lines per item; the warehouse assigns locations. If the range changes, for example through seasonal items, the classification is adjusted.
Worked example: saving walking by batching (neutral values)
Batching saves walking but adds a sorting step. It pays off when many orders contain the same items – with very different orders, processing them one by one is often simpler.
| Process | Orders | Trips through the warehouse |
|---|---|---|
| Order by order | 20 orders with 3 lines each | 20 trips |
| Batch picking with sorting | the same 20 orders in 4 waves | 4 trips plus a sorting step |
Questions to ask a provider about picking
- Is every pick scanned or only spot-checked?
- How is the error rate measured and reported?
- By when must orders arrive to be processed the same day?
- How are partial quantities handled when an item runs short?
- What data do I get back per order – packages, weight, batches?
After picking: packing and securing
A shipment picked without errors can still arrive damaged if it is poorly packed. For pallet shipments this means: heavy goods at the bottom, edge and layer protection for sensitive cartons, strapping or stretch film, and labels that stay readable after wrapping. For carton shipments filling material and weight per carton matter. What your recipients specify, such as maximum pallet height or label position, belongs in the service description. The consignor, carrier, driver and loading operator may each have duties relating to loading and securing the load on the vehicle; agree the division of tasks in advance – statutory duties still apply.
How the terms are used in practice
The terms are not used entirely consistently in literature and practice. This overview describes the methods in general; which technology a provider uses is stated in its quote.
Questions and answers: Order picking methods
What types of order picking are there?
By movement person-to-goods and goods-to-person, by order handling single-stage and two-stage, by information paper-based or paperless.
What is paperless picking?
Picking without a paper list: the picker receives the next task by scanner, light signal or voice and confirms each pick directly.
What is the difference between single-stage and two-stage picking?
Single-stage assembles each order individually. Two-stage first collects the items of several orders and then splits them between the individual orders.
How is order picking charged?
Charges per order and per order line are common, per pallet for pallet goods; packaging and labels come on top.
Which picking method is best?
That depends on order structure and the cost of errors. Few large orders favour order-by-order picking, many small ones with the same items favour two-stage picking.
What is pick by voice?
A method in which the picker hears location and quantity through a headset and confirms the pick by voice, keeping both hands free.
What is an ABC analysis in a warehouse?
A classification of items by pick frequency: A items are picked often and sit close to staging, C items rarely and further away.
What is wave picking?
Orders are bundled into waves, for example by collection time or route, and processed together, so shipments for the same collection are ready at the same time.